Skip to main content

What Would Ellen White Say to Church Leaders?

This blog post was written for the Spectrum Blog and was posted on August 15, 2012 here.

Last week I asked what Martin Luther King would say about the current ordination struggle. Today I am asking what Ellen White would say.

In The Great Controversy, White writes about Martin Luther’s experience before the Diet of Worms. In this chapter, she hails Luther as a great model of faith who was willing to stand up for his convictions despite great opposition and risk of personal peril.

During his trial at the Diet of Worms, Luther was told that he must either retract his writings or face severe consequences. White records Luther’s response:
“The Reformer answered: ‘Since your most serene majesty and your high mightinesses require from me a clear, simple, and precise answer, I will give you one, and it is this: I cannot submit my faith either to the pope or to the councils, because it is clear as the day that they have frequently erred and contradicted each other. Unless therefore I am convinced by the testimony of Scripture or by the clearest reasoning, unless I am persuaded by means of the passages I have quoted, and unless they thus render my conscience bound by the word of God, I cannot and I will not retract, for it is unsafe for a Christian to speak against his conscience. Here I stand, I can do no other; may God help me. Amen.’" (160)
In my opinion, the most disturbing part of the entire debate surrounding women’s ordination came during Elder Ted Wilson’s appearance on 3ABN last week. In an hour-long interview, he referred to those of us fighting in favor of women’s ordination as having “moral convictions.” However, the key word he kept on saying over and over again was “submission.” In Wilson’s opinion, we need to submit our moral convictions for the sake of the unity of the church.

Yet, we cannot do this because “it is unsafe for a Christian to speak against his conscience.”

White states that Luther’s bold speech had a powerful effect on all those present:
“The partisans of Rome had been worsted; their cause appeared in a most unfavorable light. They sought to maintain their power, not by appealing to the Scriptures, but by a resort to threats, Rome's unfailing argument” (161).
It has been widely noted that in the GC’s first document appealing for unity, that there was not a single mention of Scripture. They have since put out a second document which now starts with a quote from Jesus’ prayer in John 17, has a reference to Acts 15, and is titled “An Appeal for Oneness in Christ.” It appears they belatedly caught their omission and tried to fix it but their true intentions were not missed. 

The new letter also contains a carefully-worded threat when it states, “The action taken by the Columbia Union Conference represents a serious threat to the unity of the worldwide Seventh-day Adventist Church, and thus, at its next meeting in October 2012, the General Conference Executive Committee will carefully review the situation and determine how to respond.” This not only puts the Columbia Union on notice, but is also meant to warn the Pacific Union that there will be consequences if they join the Columba Union in ordaining women.

History surely repeats itself as once again those in power seek to maintain it not by appealing to Scripture, but instead, resorting to threats.

Later in the chapter, White continues to laud the great courage and conviction of Luther:
“Had the Reformer yielded a single point, Satan and his hosts would have gained the victory. But his unwavering firmness was the means of emancipating the church, and beginning a new and better era. The influence of this one man, who dared to think and act for himself in religious matters, was to affect the church and the world, not only in his own time, but in all future generations. His firmness and fidelity would strengthen all, to the close of time, who should pass through a similar experience. The power and majesty of God stood forth above the counsel of men, above the mighty power of Satan” (166).
I hope we all have that same “unwavering firmness” which will help “emancipate” this church to bring on a “new and better era.” Let us not be afraid to think and act for ourselves because it will serve as a witness for future generations.

The final quotation I will share speaks directly to Elder Wilson’s call for submission despite our moral convictions. She writes:
“After his departure, still desirous that his firmness should not be mistaken for rebellion, Luther wrote to the emperor. "God, who is the searcher of hearts, is my witness," he said, "that I am ready most earnestly to obey your majesty, in honor or in dishonor, in life or in death, and with no exception save the word of God, by which man lives. In all the affairs of this present life, my fidelity shall be unshaken, for here to lose or to gain is of no consequence to salvation. But when eternal interests are concerned, God wills not that man should submit unto man. For such submission in spiritual matters is a real worship, and ought to be rendered solely to the Creator” (167).
I have spent over 20 years in Adventist education. One of the values that was instilled in me every year was the importance of standing up for what I knew to be right, no matter the cost. I was told to think and act for myself and not allow any man to control my actions. This lesson was reinforced as we learned about the Adventist pioneers who had to leave their churches in order to stand up for their beliefs and convictions. They could not remain quiet while their churches were not living up to what they believed to be true.

As a pastor, I was taught to appeal to prospective baptismal candidates to live their lives in accordance with their newfound beliefs. To encourage them to take a stand for Christ even if their families and churches tried to pressure them into maintaining the status quo for the sake of peace and unity.

This stands in stark contrast to the messages being sent to us from the GC leadership. We are now being told that we must check our convictions at the door of the church and instead submit. While we used to applaud the pioneers for fiercely standing up for their convictions, doing the same now is seen as causing dissension and disunity.

Yet, there still is a minority, dare I say, a remnant, who believe they must stand up for their convictions. Who are unwilling to sit idly by. Who agree with Luther and refuse to submit to anyone other than God.

So, to Elder Wilson, and the other denominational leaders who are attempting to force the supporters of women’s ordination to submit to their authority, let it be clearly known:

We will not submit!


Popular posts from this blog

Life of a Pastor

It was shaping up to be a long, draining Sabbath an Adventist pastor experiences quite often. I got up around 7am and didn't finish the day until 10pm (I did get a chance to sneak a nap in so that helped). Although too long, it provided a lot of thought-provoking experiences that made it manageable. The week turned out to be filled with good news. On Monday, a member had a baby so that was exciting. Another member had back surgery on Tuesday that went well. Wednesday, one of our members' sons was had a very rare and serious surgery. It literally took all day but by late afternoon we got the great news that everything had gone well. So, we were coming to church in a celebrative mood. Then, before Sabbath School started, a mother and daughter-in-law were crying and hugging each other because another daughter-in-law was given bad news about her cancer. The doctors have told her she has two months to live. This actual is quite typical in church. You have people coming full of prais

Four Reasons We Vaccinated Our Kids Against COVID-19

At the first chance possible we took Luke (10) and Zeke (7) to get vaccinated against COVID-19. There are four reasons we made this choice that I hope might encourage other parents to do the same.  First, we trust the science and data that has undeniably shown that vaccinations work. They reduce the risk of contracting COVID-19 and even if you have a breakthrough case, the chance of hospitalization or even death are drastically reduced. You can see the overwhelming data from California here:  Without question, we have trusted our doctors and the regular immunization schedule for school. We get a flu shot every year. We give our kids Tylenol or Ibuprofen when they're sick. They’ve taken antibiotics as prescribed. We aren’t going to stop trusting our doctors now.  Second, we’re doing it to protect their grandparents and other adults with risk factors. While the risk of serious complications for them is quite low, it is high for t

The Advent Struggle

I've been trying to write this for literally a month but haven't been able to. Not sure why but it just hasn't flowed. So, here's the attempt: On a regular basis, I hear from or about friends who have stopped going to church. There are numerous reasons why they are leaving but one common thread seems to be a feeling that church has become meaningless. They've felt this for a long time but kept going because they hoped it would get better or just because they'd feel guilty if they didn't. But, they aren't going to play the game anymore. The young adult exodus out of the church isn't news to really anyone but there's something important that I think will make this crisis be more severe. When you examine recent Adventist history, there have been several crises of faith including EGW and Inspiration, Desmond Ford, and Creation/Science (to a small degree). What are the characteristics of all of them? 1. They are based on a doctrinal position and are v